• Excel spreadsheets contain information about all the qualified companies that submitted information. Note: Not all companies supply information for all fields.
  • Purchase your RBJ Premium subscription for unlimited free downloads for a year. Questions about RBJ Premium? Call 866-941-4130 or email circulation@rbj.net.
  • Single list purchases require that you log in to your RBJ or Paypal account. Individual data purchases are a one-time download and non-refundable.
  • Questions about using the database: Email research@rbj.net.

RBJ Lists: the best place for information about business in the Rochester - Finger Lakes region!

Prefer PDFs?
A printer-friendly PDF of this list is available.

Download PDF file

Prefer Excel?
A complete spreadsheet of this list is available.

Download Excel file
Commercial Insurance Firms
(Ranked by local employees)

Originally published Jan. 17, 2020.

RankCompany
Address
Website
Local
employees
agents/brokers
Top local executive
Telephone
% of premium volume that is property/casualty% commissions
and fees from commercial policies
Local offices
Year estab. locally
Type of insurance or services
1.
Paychex Insurance Agency Inc.
150 Sawgrass Drive
Rochester, NY 14620
www.paychexinsurance.com
686
319
Don Cahalan
(877) 266-6850
20.5%
49.1%
1
1997
Health, dental, vision, disability, workers' compensation, business owners’ policies, cyber liability protection, general liability, commercial auto, umbrella, employment practices liability insurance
2.
CoverWallet
7910 Lehigh Crossing
Victor, NY 14564
www.coverwallet.com
146
83
Rashmi Melgiri
(646) 844-9933
100%
100%
1
2018
General liability, workers compensation, commercial property, business owner’s policy, professional liability, directors’ and officers’ liability, cyber liability, inland marine, employment practices liability insurance (EPLI), special events
3.
Tompkins Insurance Agencies Inc.
90 Main St.
Batavia, NY 14020
www.tompkinsins.com
95
79
David Boyce
(585) 344-0833
65%
57%
11
1876
Employee benefits, personal insurance and commercial insurance